How-to

    Performance appraisal process for small and mid-size companies: cycle, forms and calibration

    Published 6 min readBy the flowwork.ai editorial teamReviewed by Anushree Rao, HR, flowwork.ai,

    Short answer

    A workable appraisal process has five steps: set goals or KRAs at the start of the cycle; run self, manager and (optionally) peer reviews in a fixed window; calibrate ratings across teams so a "4" means the same everywhere; release final ratings and have the conversation; then link ratings to increments with a hike sheet. Keep it to one annual cycle with a mid-year check-in unless your teams need more, and decide the rating scale and who sees what before you start.

    What are the steps in a performance appraisal?

    StepWhenWho
    Set goals / KRAs and weightsAprilEmployee and manager
    Mid-year check-inSeptember–OctoberEmployee and manager
    Self reviewFirst 2 weeks of MarchEmployee
    Manager and peer reviewsMarchManagers, nominated peers
    CalibrationLate March – early AprilHR and leaders
    Release ratings, conversationsAprilManagers
    Increments and hike lettersApril–MayHR and finance

    A typical annual cycle (April–March year).

    What should we decide before the cycle starts?

    • Eligibility: for example employees who joined before 1 January.
    • Rating scale: 1–5 is the most common; define each point in words.
    • Weights: how much goals/KRAs vs competencies count in the final rating.
    • Visibility: who sees peer comments, and when employees see the final rating.
    • Peers: how many, who nominates, who approves.

    What is calibration and the 9-box?

    Calibration is a meeting where leaders compare ratings across teams and adjust outliers, so ratings are fair and fit the budget. The 9-box plots each person's performance against their potential, which helps with promotions and succession.

    How flowwork.ai solves this

    1. Set up review cycles in FlowPerform with eligibility rules, self, manager and peer reviews, and your own rating scale.
    2. Goals, OKRs and KRAs carry their weights into the final rating; reminders go out automatically.
    3. The Review summariser condenses long review responses for managers.
    4. Calibration view with suggested ratings and the 9-box; ratings are released when HR decides.
    5. Hike sheets turn final ratings into increments, using salaries from HR records.

    FlowPerform is included in FlowPeople One. Not yet: one-on-one meetings. See FlowPeople and the employee handbook template.

    Frequently asked questions

    How often should a small company run appraisals?

    Once a year with a mid-year check-in suits most small and mid-size companies; quarterly goal check-ins can run alongside.

    What is a good rating scale?

    A 1–5 scale with each point defined in words is the most common and easiest to calibrate.

    What is the 9-box grid?

    A grid that plots performance against potential in three levels each, used for talent and succession decisions.

    Sources

    Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we'll correct it.

    Try flowwork.ai free

    Start with one module and add the rest when you need them.