How-to
Performance appraisal process for small and mid-size companies: cycle, forms and calibration
Short answer
A workable appraisal process has five steps: set goals or KRAs at the start of the cycle; run self, manager and (optionally) peer reviews in a fixed window; calibrate ratings across teams so a "4" means the same everywhere; release final ratings and have the conversation; then link ratings to increments with a hike sheet. Keep it to one annual cycle with a mid-year check-in unless your teams need more, and decide the rating scale and who sees what before you start.
What are the steps in a performance appraisal?
| Step | When | Who |
|---|---|---|
| Set goals / KRAs and weights | April | Employee and manager |
| Mid-year check-in | September–October | Employee and manager |
| Self review | First 2 weeks of March | Employee |
| Manager and peer reviews | March | Managers, nominated peers |
| Calibration | Late March – early April | HR and leaders |
| Release ratings, conversations | April | Managers |
| Increments and hike letters | April–May | HR and finance |
A typical annual cycle (April–March year).
What should we decide before the cycle starts?
- Eligibility: for example employees who joined before 1 January.
- Rating scale: 1–5 is the most common; define each point in words.
- Weights: how much goals/KRAs vs competencies count in the final rating.
- Visibility: who sees peer comments, and when employees see the final rating.
- Peers: how many, who nominates, who approves.
What is calibration and the 9-box?
Calibration is a meeting where leaders compare ratings across teams and adjust outliers, so ratings are fair and fit the budget. The 9-box plots each person's performance against their potential, which helps with promotions and succession.
How flowwork.ai solves this
- Set up review cycles in FlowPerform with eligibility rules, self, manager and peer reviews, and your own rating scale.
- Goals, OKRs and KRAs carry their weights into the final rating; reminders go out automatically.
- The Review summariser condenses long review responses for managers.
- Calibration view with suggested ratings and the 9-box; ratings are released when HR decides.
- Hike sheets turn final ratings into increments, using salaries from HR records.
FlowPerform is included in FlowPeople One. Not yet: one-on-one meetings. See FlowPeople and the employee handbook template.
Frequently asked questions
How often should a small company run appraisals?
Once a year with a mid-year check-in suits most small and mid-size companies; quarterly goal check-ins can run alongside.
What is a good rating scale?
A 1–5 scale with each point defined in words is the most common and easiest to calibrate.
What is the 9-box grid?
A grid that plots performance against potential in three levels each, used for talent and succession decisions.
Sources
- flowwork.ai help: Performance user guide (checked 15 November 2026)
Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we'll correct it.